COLUMBUS, Ohio - It's the holiday season rush
- and not just in stores.
Lawmakers trying to finish up the work of the 124th General
Assembly so they can adjourn - and go home - for the year have
introduced, debated and passed a flurry of bills in the month since
the Nov. 5 election.
In the waning days of the legislative session, work has centered
on some of the most contentious bills lawmakers have dealt with over
the past two years.
The bills have moved too quickly for some.
Citizens advocates worry that sending legislation through the
appropriate channels at breakneck speed cuts the public out of the
process, opens the door for sloppy legislation that doesn't pass
constitutional muster and invites corruption from politicians
looking to sneak unattractive measures into bills.
"It's bad policy to shove things right through," said Catherine
Turcer, a policy analyst with Ohio Citizen Action, a public advocacy
group.
"We have what's called a full-time legislature and if, in fact,
that's true, it makes sense to spend that time - all year - on
legislation, instead of just a few weeks."
Leaders in the Republican-controlled House and Senate have put
pressure on their caucuses to pass priority bills before the session
ends. Otherwise, the bills would have to be reintroduced in the next
session.
Over the past month:
_Both chambers passed a controversial bill increasing the number
of charter schools allowed in Ohio.
_The House and Senate approved vastly different versions of a
bill capping jury awards for patients in medical malpractice cases,
and then compromised the two versions within hours.
_The state's two-year construction budget went through committee
hearings and was passed by the House within 24 hours of being
introduced. The Senate is expected to approve it this week.
_The Senate added amendments to a House-approved bill that would
have allowed qualified Ohioans to carry concealed weapons. However,
House leaders refused to agree with the changes.
_A measure in mid-November that would have placed electronic slot
machines at Ohio racetracks prompted much debate and a vow of a veto
from Gov. Bob Taft.
While Republicans hammered out compromises on most of the bills
in lengthy closed-door caucus meetings, Democrats complained
publicly about the speed at which bills were moving.
House Speaker Larry Householder, a Republican from Glenford, said
he doesn't see a danger with passing a lot bills quickly at the end
of the legislative session.
"Most of this legislation doesn't take effect immediately. I
guess if we find out there's some problem we'll be able to fix it
pretty quickly in January," Householder said.
Why risk it, said Rep. Ed Jerse, a Democrat from Euclid who sat
on the House-Senate medical malpractice committee.
Jerse said Republicans who were in a hurry to pass a bill this
session didn't take time to ensure the measure was constitutionally
sound. He said he expects the Supreme Court will again find the bill
unconstitutional.
"What we are doing is a rushed effort that will hurt individuals
in Ohio and not do what it's intended to do," Jerse said. "We rushed
a bill that has constitutional flaws in it."
Sen. Michael Shoemaker, a Democrat from Bourneville who was on
the education committee considering the charter schools bill, said
the tight timetable meant the public didn't have a chance to voice
their opinions on last-minute changes to the bill.
"I don't think you had fair input from the education community,"
he said. "What's the harm in waiting until next session to pass
this?"
Shoemaker said a legislative report on charter schools is due
next year and that lawmakers should have waited until its findings
were released before approving a bill overhauling the system.
Perhaps the most worrisome part of so many bills being pushed
through is that lawmakers could slip in provisions without the
public's knowledge, Turcer said.
She said that happened this year when Sen. Jeff Jacobson added to
a bill an amendment eliminating the requirement that statewide and
legislative candidates file campaign finance reports electronically
beginning in January.
"It happened so quickly that it didn't even give people a chance
to figure out what the bill said, let alone act on it," Turcer
said.
However, Jacobson, a Republican from Phillipsburg, said the
amendment was added to a bill about ballot issue language in an open
committee meeting that had been publicized.
After talks with Secretary of State Kenneth Blackwell's office, a
House-Senate committee extended the deadline until March 1,
2004.